Advanced Paper Writing (APW)
Neu-Ulm University of Applied Sciences
January 8, 2027
Your job is to make it easy to say yes. Thatcher (2025b)
After completing this unit, you will be able to:
Feedback from the editor-in-chief
For each manuscript (five minutes):
The editor of the manuscript explains the decision; the lecturer comments as editor-in-chief.
20:00
Dear Professor [Name],
Please find enclosed our manuscript “[Title],” which we submit for consideration as a research article in [Journal].
The manuscript examines [research question] in [context]. Drawing on [theory] and [data and method], we show that [core finding]. The study contributes to the conversation on [conversation] in [Journal], in particular to recent work by [authors published in the journal], by [contribution].
The manuscript has not been published and is not under consideration elsewhere. All authors have approved the submission. [Required statements, e.g., on related conference papers or the use of AI tools.]
Sincerely, [Corresponding author]
| Decision | Meaning | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Desk reject | Not sent out for review (fit, contribution, quality) | Revise positioning, choose another outlet |
| Reject | Reviewed, not acceptable | Use the reviews, revise, submit elsewhere |
| Reject and resubmit | Not acceptable in its current form, new submission invited | Substantial rework, treated as a new submission |
| Major revision | Promising, substantial changes required | Revise and respond point by point |
| Minor revision | Close to acceptance | Revise and respond point by point |
| Accept | Accepted, possibly with conditions | Proofs, final files |
The history of one paper: from first draft to publication
| Issue (verbatim) | Evidence | Fix | Rule invoked | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| R1.3: “The definition of X overlaps with Y.” | p. 7, section 2.2 | Added contrastive definition and table of neighboring constructs | One construct, one paragraph | Accepted |
| R2.1: “Collect additional longitudinal data.” | p. 21, limitations | Stated temporal boundary condition; added robustness check with lagged data | Theorize, don’t speculate | Rejected (rationale and alternative) |
Response matrix
35:00
A research agenda is a long-term, strategic roadmap of interrelated studies that builds a scholarly identity (Thatcher, 2025a).
One slide, three minutes
Present your manuscript on one slide: title, model or central argument, and a one-sentence contribution.
The group gives a submission recommendation:
35:00
Your next steps
10:00
What should stay, what should change, and what was missing?