Advanced Paper Writing (APW)
Neu-Ulm University of Applied Sciences
December 17, 2026
Imagine that you enter a parlor. You come late. When you arrive, others have long preceded you, and they are engaged in a heated discussion, a discussion too heated for them to pause and tell you exactly what it is about. Burke (1941)
After completing this unit, you will be able to:
Scientific work can be viewed as a conversation among scholars (Huff, 1999).
| Level | Question | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Discipline | Which field’s standards apply? | Information Systems |
| Association and subgroup | Which community reviews and meets? | AIS; SIG on Digital Innovation, Transformation and Entrepreneurship (SIG DITE) |
| Literature strand | Which body of work forms the reference point? | Digital innovation |
| Conversation | Which ongoing debate does the paper join? | Generativity and control in digital platform ecosystems |
How authors construct the conversation they join (Locke & Golden-Biddle, 1997):
| Construction | What the author does | Signal to the reader |
|---|---|---|
| Synthesized coherence | Connects work that was not previously cited together | “These separate studies address one underlying question.” |
| Progressive coherence | Presents a line of cumulative research | “The field has advanced to this point.” |
| Non-coherence | Presents competing positions | “The field disagrees on this question.” |
Conversation detective
Present the conversation map from your preparation (four minutes each):
The group probes: Is this one conversation or several? Does the manuscript belong to it?
25:00
Your work is not suitable for every journal, and not every journal is suitable for your work.
| Ranking | Scope | Categories |
|---|---|---|
| VHB-Rating 2024 | Business research (German-speaking) | A+ to D |
| AJG (Chartered ABS) | Business and management | 4* to 1 |
| AIS Senior Scholars’ List | Information Systems | Basket of premier journals |
| FT50 | Business and management | List of 50 journals |
| Journal Citation Reports, Scopus | All disciplines | Impact metrics and quartiles |
Pro tip: The browser extension Rapid Journal Quality Check shows journal rankings (e.g., VHB, ABS, FT50, SJR, CORE) directly next to Google Scholar search results.
Journals publish different types of papers, each with its own structure and review criteria.
Reverse-engineer three to five recent exemplars from your target journal (Thatcher, 2025).
In many fields, conferences are a regular step on the way to a journal publication.
Predatory journals prioritize self-interest at the expense of scholarship (Grudniewicz et al., 2019).
Several investigations and legal cases have exposed predatory and questionable practices.
| Type | Peer review | Indexing | Main motive |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classic predatory journals | Non-existent or weak | Not indexed in major databases | Profit |
| Exploitative special-issue publishers | Often compromised | Indexed, but questionable | Profit and citation boosting |
| Paper-mill-associated journals | Fake or automated | Rarely indexed | Profit and academic fraud |
| Commercially opportunistic publishers | Sometimes weakened by commercial pressure | Indexed in major databases | Profit with mixed practices |
Outlet shortlist
25:00
Desk-reject simulation
You act as editor of a peer’s target journal (rotation: A → B → C → D → A).
40:00
Complete your outlet shortlist; together with your conversation map and the editor’s feedback, it serves as input for the assumption hunt at the end of the day.