Positioning

Advanced Paper Writing (APW)

Andy Weeger

Neu-Ulm University of Applied Sciences

December 17, 2026

Opening Remarks

The Parlor

Imagine that you enter a parlor. You come late. When you arrive, others have long preceded you, and they are engaged in a heated discussion, a discussion too heated for them to pause and tell you exactly what it is about. Burke (1941)

Learning Outcomes

After completing this unit, you will be able to:

  1. Locate your manuscript within a discipline, a literature strand, and a scholarly conversation.
  2. Map a conversation by its core outlets, authors, and concepts.
  3. Evaluate target outlets based on rankings, genres, and fit with your conversation.
  4. Distinguish reputable outlets from predatory and questionable publishers.

Conversations

Scholarship as Conversation

Scientific work can be viewed as a conversation among scholars (Huff, 1999).

  • Conversations take place in journals and at conferences.
  • They determine which questions count as interesting and which answers count as convincing.
  • Only some ideas lead to further discussion; many are ignored.
  • No conversation covers everything that could be said about a project.

Levels of Positioning

Level Question Example
Discipline Which field’s standards apply? Information Systems
Association and subgroup Which community reviews and meets? AIS; SIG on Digital Innovation, Transformation and Entrepreneurship (SIG DITE)
Literature strand Which body of work forms the reference point? Digital innovation
Conversation Which ongoing debate does the paper join? Generativity and control in digital platform ecosystems
Table 1: Levels of positioning a manuscript

Recognizing a Conversation

  • Shared questions: papers address related problems and cite each other.
  • Shared concepts: a stable vocabulary of concepts and constructs.
  • Shared venues: special issues, conference tracks, and recurring publication clusters.
  • Core authors: a limited group of scholars who contribute and review.
  • Dominant procedures: typical theories and methods that set the quality standard.

Joining a Conversation

How authors construct the conversation they join (Locke & Golden-Biddle, 1997):

Construction What the author does Signal to the reader
Synthesized coherence Connects work that was not previously cited together “These separate studies address one underlying question.”
Progressive coherence Presents a line of cumulative research “The field has advanced to this point.”
Non-coherence Presents competing positions “The field disagrees on this question.”
Table 2: Ways of structuring intertextual coherence according to Locke & Golden-Biddle (1997)

Exercise

Conversation detective

Present the conversation map from your preparation (four minutes each):

  1. The conversation in one phrase (more specific than the literature strand)
  2. The core papers and which of them your manuscript cites
  3. A maximum of five journals, five authors, and five concepts or constructs
  4. The construction you use to present the conversation (synthesized, progressive, or non-coherent)

The group probes: Is this one conversation or several? Does the manuscript belong to it?

25:00

Outlets

Outlet Choice

Your work is not suitable for every journal, and not every journal is suitable for your work.

  • Conversation fit: Does the outlet publish the conversation you join?
  • Genre fit: Does it publish your type of paper?
  • Level fit: Does the ranking match the maturity of your contribution?
  • Practical fit: turnaround time, open access fees, and the requirements of your doctoral regulations

Rankings

Ranking Scope Categories
VHB-Rating 2024 Business research (German-speaking) A+ to D
AJG (Chartered ABS) Business and management 4* to 1
AIS Senior Scholars’ List Information Systems Basket of premier journals
FT50 Business and management List of 50 journals
Journal Citation Reports, Scopus All disciplines Impact metrics and quartiles
Table 3: Common journal rankings and indicators

Pro tip: The browser extension Rapid Journal Quality Check shows journal rankings (e.g., VHB, ABS, FT50, SJR, CORE) directly next to Google Scholar search results.

Paper Genres

Journals publish different types of papers, each with its own structure and review criteria.

  • Empirical: quantitative, qualitative, or mixed-methods studies
  • Conceptual: theory development without new data
  • Review: systematic, narrative, or theory-building reviews of a literature
  • Design-oriented: artifacts and design knowledge (e.g., design science research)
  • Short formats: research notes, commentaries, research-in-progress papers

Model the Journal

Reverse-engineer three to five recent exemplars from your target journal (Thatcher, 2025).

  • How do introductions open and where does the research question appear?
  • How are theory and hypotheses or propositions connected?
  • How are methods and results presented (tables, figures, robustness)?
  • How do discussions close?

Conferences

In many fields, conferences are a regular step on the way to a journal publication.

  • Conferences provide feedback and visibility before journal submission.
  • Conference tracks show current conversations and their participants.
  • Doctoral consortia offer feedback from senior scholars.
  • Check the prior-publication policy of your target journal.

Predatory Journals

Predatory journals prioritize self-interest at the expense of scholarship (Grudniewicz et al., 2019).

  • False or misleading information
  • Deviation from best editorial and publication practices
  • Lack of transparency
  • Aggressive and indiscriminate solicitation

Documented Cases

Several investigations and legal cases have exposed predatory and questionable practices.

  • Sting operation: a deliberately flawed fake paper was accepted by 157 of 304 open-access journals (Bohannon, 2013).
  • Fake editor: a fictitious scholar was accepted as editor by 48 of 360 journals she applied to; none of them was listed in the Journal Citation Reports (Sorokowski et al., 2017).
  • Court ruling: in 2019, a US federal court ordered the publisher OMICS International to pay more than USD 50 million for deceptive publishing practices.
  • Mass retractions: in 2023, Wiley retracted thousands of papers from special issues of its Hindawi journals after detecting paper-mill activity (Van Noorden, 2023).

Questionable Outlets

Type Peer review Indexing Main motive
Classic predatory journals Non-existent or weak Not indexed in major databases Profit
Exploitative special-issue publishers Often compromised Indexed, but questionable Profit and citation boosting
Paper-mill-associated journals Fake or automated Rarely indexed Profit and academic fraud
Commercially opportunistic publishers Sometimes weakened by commercial pressure Indexed in major databases Profit with mixed practices
Table 4: Working typology of predatory and questionable outlets

Exercise

Outlet shortlist

  1. Select three outlets from your conversation map: a stretch target, a realistic target, and a fallback.
  2. For each, note its ranking in the list your program uses and the paper category that fits your manuscript.
  3. Choose three exemplar papers from your realistic target that are close to your paper in topic and genre.
  4. Discuss your choice in pairs: does the outlet publish your conversation?
25:00

Exercise

Desk-reject simulation

You act as editor of a peer’s target journal (rotation: A → B → C → D → A).

  1. Read the aims and scope of the journal, then the title, abstract, and introduction of the manuscript (15 minutes).
  2. Decide: desk reject or send out for review.
  3. Justify the decision with three reasons, written in the voice of an editor.
  4. Present the decision (five minutes per manuscript); the author listens and does not defend.
40:00

Homework

Complete your outlet shortlist; together with your conversation map and the editor’s feedback, it serves as input for the assumption hunt at the end of the day.

Q&A

Literature

Bohannon, J. (2013). Who’s afraid of peer review? Science, 342(6154), 60–65. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.342.6154.60
Burke, K. (1941). The philosophy of literary form: Studies in symbolic action. Louisiana State University Press.
Grudniewicz, A., Moher, D., Cobey, K. D., et al. (2019). Predatory journals: No definition, no defence. Nature, 576(7786), 210–212. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-019-03759-y
Huff, A. S. (1999). Writing for scholarly publication. Sage.
Locke, K., & Golden-Biddle, K. (1997). Constructing opportunities for contribution: Structuring intertextual coherence and "problematizing" in organizational studies. Academy of Management Journal, 40(5), 1023–1062. https://doi.org/10.2307/256926
Sorokowski, P., Kulczycki, E., Sorokowska, A., & Pisanski, K. (2017). Predatory journals recruit fake editor. Nature, 543(7646), 481–483. https://doi.org/10.1038/543481a
Thatcher, J. B. (2025). Rules for writing elite information systems papers: Field notes for my PhD students. Unpublished manuscript, Leeds School of Business, University of Colorado Boulder.
Van Noorden, R. (2023). More than 10,000 research papers were retracted in 2023: A new record. Nature, 624(7992), 479–481. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-023-03974-8
Verband der Hochschullehrerinnen und Hochschullehrer für Betriebswirtschaft. (2024). VHB-Rating 2024. VHB.