Knowledge Process

Advanced Paper Writing (APW)

Andy Weeger

Neu-Ulm University of Applied Sciences

January 8, 2027

Opening Remarks

Statistical Equivalence

Models with excellent fit tell us little about the data-generating mechanisms. Fried (2020, p. 275)

Learning Outcomes

After completing this unit, you will be able to:

  1. Explain the functions of theory and its building blocks.
  2. Distinguish deductive, inductive, and abductive logics of theory development.
  3. Classify your manuscript along the three pathways of empirical research in theory development.
  4. Analyze the alignment of paradigm, theory, method, and claims in your manuscript and in your conversation.

Theorizing

Why Theorizing Matters

Theories exist along a continuum from vague hunches to detailed accounts of causal mechanisms (Weick, 1989).

  • Early theorizing creates constructs and narratives for an observed phenomenon.
  • Theorizing matters most where phenomena are not straightforward and mechanisms are not obvious (Bendoly & Oliva, 2025).

Functions of Theory

Three functions of theory in empirical research (Bendoly & Oliva, 2025):

  • Inspiring work: theory serves as a seed for new inquiries, even when it is still unrefined.
  • Motivating design: theoretical arguments are the warrants for hypotheses or propositions.
  • Aiding interpretation: theory helps to make sense of new observations and patterns.

Building Blocks

Element Level Description
Construct Abstract A concept chosen or created to explain a phenomenon; not directly observable
Variable Observable An observable entity that can take two or more values
Proposition Abstract A statement of relationship among constructs
Hypothesis Observable A statement of relationship among variables
Table 1: Building blocks of theory according to Bacharach (1989)

Types of Theory

Type Purpose Example question
I. Analysis Describe and classify What kinds of digital platforms exist?
II. Explanation Explain how and why, without precise prediction How do professionals deal with opaque AI results?
III. Prediction Predict without explaining Which firms will adopt AI?
IV. Explanation and prediction Explain and predict, with testable propositions Why and to what extent does CIO presence increase AI orientation?
V. Design and action Prescribe how to do something How should an AI-based decision support system be designed?
Table 2: Types of theory in information systems according to Gregor (2006)

Pathways

Logics of Inference

Logic Direction Conclusion
Deduction From theory to specific predictions Follows necessarily if the premises are true
Induction From observed instances to a generalization Probable, strengthened by further observations
Abduction From a surprising observation to the best explanation Plausible, a conjecture to be examined further
Table 3: Logics of inference

Three Paths

Three ways empirical research contributes to theory development (Bendoly & Oliva, 2025):

  • Path A: Testing theoretical claims (deduction): experiments, quasi-experiments, and secondary data analysis refute or support claims derived from theory.
  • Path B: Observation and explanation (abduction and induction): researchers observe real-world processes; regularities that existing theory cannot explain call for new constructs and explanations.
  • Paths A and B: Intervention-based research: researchers apply theory to solve a real-world problem and refine the theory based on the outcome.

Exercise

Your path

Based on your preparation, present in three minutes:

  1. Which logic dominates your manuscript (deductive, inductive, abductive)?
  2. Which path does it follow (A, B, or A and B)?
  3. Which type of theory does it develop?
  4. Where in the text does a reader see this?

The group checks whether introduction, method, and discussion tell the same story.

30:00

Paradigms

Assumptions

Assumption Question Poles
Ontological What is the nature of reality? Realism vs. constructivism
Epistemological How can we know about it? Positivism vs. anti-positivism
Methodological Which procedures produce knowledge? Deductive vs. inductive
Axiological Which role do values play in research? Value-free vs. value-laden
Table 4: Philosophical assumptions underlying research

Paradigms

Three research paradigms in information systems (Orlikowski & Baroudi, 1991):

Paradigm View of reality Aim Typical evidence
Positivist Objective, independent of the observer Test theory, predict Formal propositions, measurement, hypothesis tests, generalization from samples
Interpretive Socially constructed through meanings Understand meanings and contexts Accounts of participants, in-depth case studies
Critical Historically constituted, shaped by power Critique and transform the status quo Analysis of contradictions, conflicts, and structures of domination
Table 5: Research paradigms according to Orlikowski & Baroudi (1991)

Methods Framework

Direct observation of object reality People’s perceptions of object reality Artificial reconstruction of object reality
Axiomatic Reason, logic, theorems; normative and descriptive modeling
Logical positivist / empiricist Field studies, field experiments Structured interviewing, survey research Prototyping, physical modeling, laboratory experimentation, simulation
Interpretive Action research, case studies Historical analysis, Delphi, intensive interviewing, expert panels, futures and scenarios Conceptual modeling, hermeneutics
Critical theory Introspective reflection
Table 6: Framework of research methods, adapted from Meredith et al. (1989)

Alignment

Paradigm → logic → method → claim → conversation

  • The paradigm determines which claims count as knowledge.
  • The logic of theory development determines which kind of claim the study makes.
  • The method has to be able to produce that claim.
  • The claim has to match what the conversation recognizes as a contribution.

Paradigm Hot Seat

Defend the alignment of your manuscript.

Per manuscript, 10 minutes:

  1. Present (3 minutes): paradigm, logic, method, and claim of your manuscript, and the dominant methods of your conversation (from your conversation map).
  2. Challenge (5 minutes): an assigned peer acts as a reviewer from a different paradigm and questions the alignment.
  3. Reflect (2 minutes): the group names the strongest objection; the author notes how the manuscript could address it.
40:00

Homework

Note the strongest objection from the hot seat and one sentence on how your manuscript will address it. Bring both to the afternoon session; they enter your response matrix and your publication plan.

Q&A

Literature

Bacharach, S. B. (1989). Organizational theories: Some criteria for evaluation. Academy of Management Review, 14(4), 496–515.
Bendoly, E., & Oliva, R. (2025). Meaningful theoretical pathways for research contributions. Journal of Operations Management, 70, 1039–1050.
Fried, E. I. (2020). Lack of theory building and testing impedes progress in the factor and network literature. Psychological Inquiry, 31(4), 271–288. https://doi.org/10.1080/1047840X.2020.1853461
Gregor, S. (2006). The nature of theory in information systems. MIS Quarterly, 30(3), 611–642.
Markus, K. A. (2008). Constructs, concepts and the worlds of possibility: Connecting the measurement, manipulation, and meaning of variables. Measurement: Interdisciplinary Research and Perspectives, 6(1–2), 54–77.
Meredith, J. R., Raturi, A., Amoako-Gyampah, K., & Kaplan, B. (1989). Alternative research paradigms in operations. Journal of Operations Management, 8(4), 297–326.
Orlikowski, W. J., & Baroudi, J. J. (1991). Studying information technology in organizations: Research approaches and assumptions. Information Systems Research, 2(1), 1–28. https://doi.org/10.1287/isre.2.1.1
Weick, K. E. (1989). Theory construction as disciplined imagination. Academy of Management Review, 14(4), 516–531.
Wynn, D., & Williams, C. K. (2012). Principles for conducting critical realist case study research in information systems. MIS Quarterly, 36(3), 787–810.