Advanced Paper Writing (APW)
Neu-Ulm University of Applied Sciences
January 8, 2027
Models with excellent fit tell us little about the data-generating mechanisms. Fried (2020, p. 275)
After completing this unit, you will be able to:
Theories exist along a continuum from vague hunches to detailed accounts of causal mechanisms (Weick, 1989).
Three functions of theory in empirical research (Bendoly & Oliva, 2025):
| Element | Level | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Construct | Abstract | A concept chosen or created to explain a phenomenon; not directly observable |
| Variable | Observable | An observable entity that can take two or more values |
| Proposition | Abstract | A statement of relationship among constructs |
| Hypothesis | Observable | A statement of relationship among variables |
| Type | Purpose | Example question |
|---|---|---|
| I. Analysis | Describe and classify | What kinds of digital platforms exist? |
| II. Explanation | Explain how and why, without precise prediction | How do professionals deal with opaque AI results? |
| III. Prediction | Predict without explaining | Which firms will adopt AI? |
| IV. Explanation and prediction | Explain and predict, with testable propositions | Why and to what extent does CIO presence increase AI orientation? |
| V. Design and action | Prescribe how to do something | How should an AI-based decision support system be designed? |
| Logic | Direction | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Deduction | From theory to specific predictions | Follows necessarily if the premises are true |
| Induction | From observed instances to a generalization | Probable, strengthened by further observations |
| Abduction | From a surprising observation to the best explanation | Plausible, a conjecture to be examined further |
Three ways empirical research contributes to theory development (Bendoly & Oliva, 2025):
Your path
Based on your preparation, present in three minutes:
The group checks whether introduction, method, and discussion tell the same story.
30:00
| Assumption | Question | Poles |
|---|---|---|
| Ontological | What is the nature of reality? | Realism vs. constructivism |
| Epistemological | How can we know about it? | Positivism vs. anti-positivism |
| Methodological | Which procedures produce knowledge? | Deductive vs. inductive |
| Axiological | Which role do values play in research? | Value-free vs. value-laden |
Three research paradigms in information systems (Orlikowski & Baroudi, 1991):
| Paradigm | View of reality | Aim | Typical evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Positivist | Objective, independent of the observer | Test theory, predict | Formal propositions, measurement, hypothesis tests, generalization from samples |
| Interpretive | Socially constructed through meanings | Understand meanings and contexts | Accounts of participants, in-depth case studies |
| Critical | Historically constituted, shaped by power | Critique and transform the status quo | Analysis of contradictions, conflicts, and structures of domination |
| Direct observation of object reality | People’s perceptions of object reality | Artificial reconstruction of object reality | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Axiomatic | Reason, logic, theorems; normative and descriptive modeling | ||
| Logical positivist / empiricist | Field studies, field experiments | Structured interviewing, survey research | Prototyping, physical modeling, laboratory experimentation, simulation |
| Interpretive | Action research, case studies | Historical analysis, Delphi, intensive interviewing, expert panels, futures and scenarios | Conceptual modeling, hermeneutics |
| Critical theory | Introspective reflection |
Paradigm → logic → method → claim → conversation
Defend the alignment of your manuscript.
Per manuscript, 10 minutes:
40:00
Note the strongest objection from the hot seat and one sentence on how your manuscript will address it. Bring both to the afternoon session; they enter your response matrix and your publication plan.