Advanced Paper Writing (APW)
Neu-Ulm University of Applied Sciences
December 17, 2026
Readers find a theory interesting when it denies an assumption they hold (Davis, 1971).
After completing this unit, you will be able to:
| Type | What is missing | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Theoretical | An explanation of how or why concepts relate | Mechanisms linking X and Y are unexplained |
| Empirical | Evidence on a phenomenon or relationship | No longitudinal evidence on the effects of X |
| Methodological | An adequate way of studying a question | Self-reported measures dominate a behavioral question |
| Conceptual | Clear, shared definitions | Studies define “digital transformation” inconsistently |
| Contextual | Coverage of settings, periods, or regions | Findings come from a single industry or country |
Three modes of constructing research questions from gaps (Sandberg & Alvesson, 2011):
| Mode | Variant | Typical phrase |
|---|---|---|
| Confusion spotting | Competing explanations | “The evidence on X is inconsistent.” |
| Neglect spotting | Overlooked area | “No study has examined X.” |
| Under-researched area | “Little is known about X.” | |
| Lack of empirical support | “Claims about X have not been tested.” | |
| Application spotting | Extension to a new area | “Theory T has not been applied to X.” |
Problematization identifies and challenges the assumptions underlying existing theory (Alvesson & Sandberg, 2011).
| Assumption type | What is assumed |
|---|---|
| In-house | Ideas shared within a specific school of thought |
| Root metaphor | Broader images of the subject matter |
| Paradigm | Ontological, epistemological, and methodological positions |
| Ideology | Political, moral, and gender-related positions |
| Field | Assumptions shared across schools within a field |
How published papers problematize the literature they construct (Locke & Golden-Biddle, 1997):
Start from an emerging phenomenon and identify the theoretical puzzle behind it (Thatcher, 2025a).
| Scientific utility | Practical utility | |
|---|---|---|
| Incremental insight | Extends a theory step by step | Refines guidance for practice |
| Revelatory insight | Changes how researchers see a phenomenon | Changes how practitioners see a problem |
Lead with what you show, not with what the literature lacks (Thatcher, 2025b).
We contribute by [mechanism or boundary condition] explaining [X → Y] for [literature or audience].
Which assumptions does your conversation take for granted?
Per manuscript, 15 minutes:
60:00
Which types of assumptions were easiest to find, and which would reviewers accept as worth challenging?
Revise your elevator pitch.
10:00
Before the second day: