Contribution

Advanced Paper Writing (APW)

Andy Weeger

Neu-Ulm University of Applied Sciences

December 17, 2026

Opening Remarks

Interesting Research

Readers find a theory interesting when it denies an assumption they hold (Davis, 1971).

Learning Outcomes

After completing this unit, you will be able to:

  1. Classify research gaps by type and by the way they are constructed.
  2. Apply problematization to identify assumptions in your conversation.
  3. Locate your contribution along the dimensions of originality and utility.
  4. Formulate a one-sentence contribution statement for your manuscript.
  5. Assess the positioning of your peers’ manuscripts.

Research Gaps

Gap Types

Type What is missing Example
Theoretical An explanation of how or why concepts relate Mechanisms linking X and Y are unexplained
Empirical Evidence on a phenomenon or relationship No longitudinal evidence on the effects of X
Methodological An adequate way of studying a question Self-reported measures dominate a behavioral question
Conceptual Clear, shared definitions Studies define “digital transformation” inconsistently
Contextual Coverage of settings, periods, or regions Findings come from a single industry or country
Table 1: Working typology of research gaps [compiled from course material; see also Thatcher (2025a)]

Gap Spotting

Three modes of constructing research questions from gaps (Sandberg & Alvesson, 2011):

Mode Variant Typical phrase
Confusion spotting Competing explanations “The evidence on X is inconsistent.”
Neglect spotting Overlooked area “No study has examined X.”
Under-researched area “Little is known about X.”
Lack of empirical support “Claims about X have not been tested.”
Application spotting Extension to a new area “Theory T has not been applied to X.”
Table 2: Modes of gap spotting according to Sandberg & Alvesson (2011)

Gap-Spotting Limits

  • That a topic is unstudied does not make it worth studying.
  • Gap spotting accepts the assumptions of existing theory.
  • It tends to produce incremental contributions.
  • It is the safer and less impactful route (Thatcher, 2025a).

Problematization

Definition

Problematization identifies and challenges the assumptions underlying existing theory (Alvesson & Sandberg, 2011).

Assumption type What is assumed
In-house Ideas shared within a specific school of thought
Root metaphor Broader images of the subject matter
Paradigm Ontological, epistemological, and methodological positions
Ideology Political, moral, and gender-related positions
Field Assumptions shared across schools within a field
Table 3: Types of assumptions open to problematization according to Alvesson & Sandberg (2011)

Problematizing Modes

How published papers problematize the literature they construct (Locke & Golden-Biddle, 1997):

  • Incomplete: the literature is not finished; the study fills in.
  • Inadequate: the literature overlooks a perspective that changes the picture.
  • Incommensurate: the literature is misguided; the study offers an alternative.

Phenomenon-Driven Inquiry

Start from an emerging phenomenon and identify the theoretical puzzle behind it (Thatcher, 2025a).

  • The phenomenon provides relevance (e.g., generative AI in knowledge work).
  • The puzzle provides the contribution: what existing theory fails to explain about it.
  • The route is harder and potentially more impactful than gap spotting.

Contribution

Contribution Dimensions

Scientific utility Practical utility
Incremental insight Extends a theory step by step Refines guidance for practice
Revelatory insight Changes how researchers see a phenomenon Changes how practitioners see a problem
Table 4: Dimensions of theoretical contribution according to Corley & Gioia (2011)

Contribution Statement

Lead with what you show, not with what the literature lacks (Thatcher, 2025b).

We contribute by [mechanism or boundary condition] explaining [X → Y] for [literature or audience].

  • Weak: “With the growing use of information systems, researchers have become increasingly interested in user attitudes.”
  • Strong: “We define IT mindfulness as a user’s dynamic capability and validate its influence on task adaptation and feature use.”

Assumption Hunt

Assumption Hunt

Which assumptions does your conversation take for granted?

Per manuscript, 15 minutes:

  1. Brief (2 minutes): the author introduces the conversation and its central claim.
  2. Hunt (8 minutes): the group collects assumptions of the conversation and classifies them (in-house, root metaphor, paradigm, ideology, field); the author listens and takes notes.
  3. Choice (5 minutes): the author selects one assumption the manuscript could challenge or qualify and explains how.
60:00

Debrief

Which types of assumptions were easiest to find, and which would reviewers accept as worth challenging?

Exercise

Revise your elevator pitch.

  1. Classify the gap your manuscript addresses: gap type and gap-spotting mode, or the assumption you selected in the assumption hunt.
  2. Locate the intended contribution in the originality-utility matrix.
  3. Rewrite your contribution sentence from the morning, taking the editor’s feedback into account.
10:00

Homework

Before the second day:

  1. Finalize your contribution sentence based on the desk-reject simulation and the assumption hunt.
  2. Read the three exemplar papers from your target outlet and note where their introductions place the motivation, the research question, and the contribution.
  3. Read Thatcher (2025b), Rules 6 to 17.
  4. Bring the introduction and one theory or background section of your manuscript.

Q&A

Literature

Alvesson, M., & Sandberg, J. (2011). Generating research questions through problematization. Academy of Management Review, 36(2), 247–271.
Corley, K. G., & Gioia, D. A. (2011). Building theory about theory building: What constitutes a theoretical contribution? Academy of Management Review, 36(1), 12–32. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2009.0486
Davis, M. S. (1971). That’s interesting! Towards a phenomenology of sociology and a sociology of phenomenology. Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 1(4), 309–344. https://doi.org/10.1177/004839317100100211
Locke, K., & Golden-Biddle, K. (1997). Constructing opportunities for contribution: Structuring intertextual coherence and "problematizing" in organizational studies. Academy of Management Journal, 40(5), 1023–1062. https://doi.org/10.2307/256926
Sandberg, J., & Alvesson, M. (2011). Ways of constructing research questions: Gap-spotting or problematization? Organization, 18(1), 23–44. https://doi.org/10.1177/1350508410372151
Thatcher, J. B. (2025a). From question to contribution: Crafting a research agenda for UT Dallas journals in OM and IS. Invited presentation, Shenzhen University.
Thatcher, J. B. (2025b). Rules for writing elite information systems papers: Field notes for my PhD students. Unpublished manuscript, Leeds School of Business, University of Colorado Boulder.