Manuscript Architecture

Advanced Paper Writing (APW)

Andy Weeger

Neu-Ulm University of Applied Sciences

December 18, 2026

Opening Remarks

Claim and Support

Strong papers begin with a claim and end by showing support for it. Thatcher (2025)

Learning Outcomes

After completing this unit, you will be able to:

  1. Structure a manuscript according to its genre and the conventions of the target outlet.
  2. Write an introduction that answers the questions reviewers ask first.
  3. Open the introduction and the abstract with a claim instead of background.
  4. Build paragraphs around topic sentences and connect them through their information flow.
  5. Argue concept-centric, with stable definitions and labels across the manuscript.

Paper Structure

Structure by Genre

Empirical paper Conceptual paper Review paper
Introduction Introduction Introduction
Theoretical background, hypotheses or propositions Conceptual foundations Conceptual background
Method (data, measures, analysis) Theory development (model, propositions) Review method
Results or findings Illustration or application Findings (descriptive, synthesis)
Discussion (contributions, implications, limitations) Discussion Discussion and research agenda
Conclusion Conclusion Conclusion
Table 1: Typical macro-structures by paper genre

The Hourglass

  • The introduction moves from the general problem to the specific question.
  • The middle sections stay narrow: theory, method, and results for this study.
  • The discussion moves from the specific findings back to the general significance.
  • Introduction and conclusion mirror each other (Bem, 1987).

Exercise

Exemplar mapping

Using the three exemplar papers from your homework:

  1. Where do the motivation, the research question, and the contribution appear (paragraph number)?
  2. How long is the introduction (paragraphs, pages)?
  3. Where does your manuscript deviate from this pattern?

Share one observation with the group.

10:00

Introduction

Three Questions

An effective introduction answers three questions (Grant & Pollock, 2011):

Question Elements of the introduction
Who cares? Topic, its relevance for theory and practice
What do we know, what don’t we know, and so what? State of research, gap or problematization, why it matters
What will we learn? Research question, approach, contribution
Table 2: Questions an introduction answers according to Grant & Pollock (2011)

Opening Moves

Open with a claim or a puzzle, not with background (Thatcher, 2025).

  • Weak: “The IS field has long been interested in digital transformation.”
  • Strong: “This paper shows that CIO presence, often ignored in emerging markets, substantially predicts a firm’s AI orientation.”

Narrative Hooks

A hook creates tension that the paper resolves (Thatcher, 2025):

  • Paradox: “Why do firms invest in AI but fail to use it strategically?”
  • Surprising fact: “Despite similar resources, some hospitals drastically outperform others in cybersecurity compliance.”
  • Theoretical contradiction: “Current theories predict X, but we observe Y.”

Contribution First

  • The gap motivates the study; the contribution states its result.
  • Name the contribution within the first two to three paragraphs.
  • Pass the inverted pyramid test: the most important point comes first.

Abstract

Exercise

Abstract tournament

You receive six anonymized abstracts: yours, your peers’, and two published exemplars.

  1. Rank them: which paper would you read first?
  2. Note for your top and bottom abstract what made the difference.
  3. Reveal and discuss: which criteria did the group use?
20:00

Abstract Elements

  1. What the objectives of the study are
  2. How the study was done
  3. Which results it obtained
  4. What the significance of the results is

State the contribution within the first two sentences (Thatcher, 2025).

Exercise

Opening rewrite

  1. Rewrite the first paragraph of your introduction so that it opens with a claim or a puzzle.
  2. Rewrite the first two sentences of your abstract so that they state what you do and find.
  3. Read both versions aloud to the group (two minutes each); the group answers: what is the paper about, and why does it matter?
30:00

Paragraphs

Topic Sentences

Each paragraph opens with a short claim that the rest of the paragraph develops.

  • The first sentence states the point; the others support it.
  • Reading only the first sentences conveys the argument (Thatcher, 2025).
  • One paragraph, one idea.

Paragraph Logic

  • Setup: the claim or question of the paragraph
  • Action: the argument, evidence, or explanation
  • Implication: what follows for the next step of the argument

Old Before New

Readers expect familiar information at the beginning of a sentence and new information at the end (Gopen & Swan, 1990).

  • The topic position links back to what the reader already knows.
  • The stress position carries the new point.
  • A paragraph can begin with a central term from the last sentence of the preceding paragraph.

Exercise

Teach-back

You work with the introduction of a peer (rotation: A → B → C → D → A).

  1. Extract the first sentence of each paragraph into a new document (5 minutes).
  2. Reconstruct the argument of the introduction in three sentences, based only on these first sentences (5 minutes).
  3. Present your reconstruction (three minutes each); the author compares it with the intended argument.
40:00

Concepts

Concept-Centric Argumentation

Organize the literature around concepts, not around authors (Webster & Watson, 2002).

  • Author-centric: “Smith (2019) found … Jones (2020) showed … Lee (2021) argued …”
  • Concept-centric: “Digital platforms coordinate complementors through boundary resources (Eaton et al., 2015; Ghazawneh & Henfridsson, 2013) …”

One Construct, One Paragraph

Each focal construct gets its own paragraph with three elements (Thatcher, 2025):

  1. A one-sentence definition
  2. Its boundaries to neighboring constructs
  3. Its position in the nomological network
  • Weak: “IT mindfulness refers to a construct that helps users be better at IT use.”
  • Strong: “IT mindfulness is a user’s dynamic capability to notice new information, remain contextually aware, and adjust IT use intentionally.”

Thread the Construct

Section Before revision After revision
Abstract IT mindfulness IT mindfulness
Theory technological awareness IT mindfulness
Hypotheses tech attentiveness IT mindfulness
Figure 1 mindful IT use IT mindfulness
Discussion IT flexibility IT mindfulness
Table 3: Label drift across sections, adapted from Thatcher (2025)

Exercise

Label audit

  1. List the three to five central concepts or constructs of your manuscript.
  2. Search each label with Control-F; note every variant and where it appears.
  3. Check whether each concept has a definition paragraph with definition, boundaries, and relations.
15:00

Homework

Bring the discussion section (or, for early drafts, the planned discussion and limitations) of your manuscript to the afternoon session.

Q&A

Literature

Bem, D. J. (1987). Writing the empirical journal article. In M. P. Zanna & J. M. Darley (Eds.), The compleat academic: A practical guide for the beginning social scientist (pp. 171–201). Random House.
Eaton, B., Elaluf-Calderwood, S., Sørensen, C., & Yoo, Y. (2015). Distributed tuning of boundary resources: The case of Apple’s iOS service system. MIS Quarterly, 39(1), 217–243.
Ghazawneh, A., & Henfridsson, O. (2013). Balancing platform control and external contribution in third-party development: The boundary resources model. Information Systems Journal, 23(2), 173–192. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2575.2012.00406.x
Gopen, G. D., & Swan, J. A. (1990). The science of scientific writing. American Scientist, 78(6), 550–558.
Grant, A. M., & Pollock, T. G. (2011). Publishing in AMJ—part 3: Setting the hook. Academy of Management Journal, 54(5), 873–879.
Recker, J. (2021). Scientific research in information systems: A beginner’s guide (2nd ed.). Springer.
Thatcher, J. B. (2025). Rules for writing elite information systems papers: Field notes for my PhD students. Unpublished manuscript, Leeds School of Business, University of Colorado Boulder.
Webster, J., & Watson, R. T. (2002). Analyzing the past to prepare for the future: Writing a literature review. MIS Quarterly, 26(2), xiii–xxiii.
Weick, K. E. (1989). Theory construction as disciplined imagination. Academy of Management Review, 14(4), 516–531.