Motivation
Write so scholars will cite it, but others will understand it. Thatcher (2025)
Thatcher calls this standard the “May Maxim,” after his mentor, the historian Dean May. It sets the bar for this course: a paper has to meet the rigor expectations of a specific scholarly community and still be clear enough that a smart reader from outside that community understands what it claims and why it matters.
Contents
The course takes a manuscript you are working on and moves it closer to submission: you position it in a scholarly conversation, sharpen its argument, check its theoretical and methodological foundations, and prepare it for the review process.
The core curriculum covers:
- Positioning and outlets: discipline, literature strand, and conversation; journal rankings, genres, and questionable outlets
- Research gaps and contributions: gap spotting, problematization, and contribution statements (Corley & Gioia, 2011; Sandberg & Alvesson, 2011)
- Manuscript architecture: paper structure by genre, introductions and abstracts, paragraph logic, concept-centric argumentation (Thatcher, 2025; Webster & Watson, 2002)
- Argument and revision: mechanisms, discussion and boundary conditions, style, and systematic revision diagnostics
- Theorizing and paradigms: deductive, inductive, and abductive pathways; the alignment of paradigm, theory, method, and claims (Bendoly & Oliva, 2025; Orlikowski & Baroudi, 1991)
- Review and publication: submission, editorial decisions, response letters, and scholarly communities
Learning Outcomes
Positioning
After completing this course, you will be able to:
- Position your contribution precisely within a discipline, a literature strand, and a scholarly conversation.
- Evaluate target outlets based on relevant rankings and genres, and distinguish reputable outlets from predatory journals.
Writing
- Structure single manuscripts (abstract, introduction, main part, discussion) for their audience, with clear paragraph logic and concept-centric argumentation.
- Articulate research gaps precisely and align the line of argument consistently with the state of research.
Knowledge Process
- Reflect critically on your research path with regard to deductive, inductive, and abductive logics of theory development, and justify it methodologically.
- Analyze the relationship between the central concepts and constructs of your conversation, the methods applied, and the underlying paradigms (e.g., positivism, interpretivism).
Publishing
- Provide qualified peer feedback on your own and others’ drafts, and process review comments constructively.
- Manage submissions, editorial decisions, and interactions with journals and scholarly communities (e.g., divisions, special interest groups, doctoral consortia) independently.
Learning Set-Up
The course runs on three on-site days at HNU and works with the manuscripts you bring.
- Each block combines a short input with an exercise on your own manuscript.
- In peer rounds, the group works on each manuscript in turn (e.g., as editors in a desk-reject simulation).
- Between the second and the third day, you revise your manuscript and act as reviewer and editor for your peers in a mock review round.
Effort
You will gain 1 ECTS for this course.
- Joint learning time (three on-site days): approx. 40%
- Self-study (preparation, revision, written peer review): approx. 60%
There is no graded assessment. The course builds on the course Paper Reviewing, Writing, and Publishing and is intended for doctoral candidates from their second semester onward.
Schedule
| Day | Topics | Units |
|---|---|---|
| Thu, 17.12.2026 | Kick-off and elevator pitches; scholarly conversations; outlets and rankings; desk-reject simulation; research gaps and problematization; assumption hunt | Positioning, Contribution |
| Fri, 18.12.2026 | Paper structure, introduction, and abstract; paragraphs and concept-centric argumentation; mechanisms and discussion; style and revision; paragraph surgery | Manuscript Architecture, Argument and Revision |
| Fri, 08.01.2027 | Logics of theory development; paradigms and alignment; submission, decisions, and responses; communities and research agenda | Knowledge Process, Publishing |
Preparation
All preparatory work at a glance:
| Due | Task | For |
|---|---|---|
| 03.12.2026 | Upload manuscript, positioning sheet, and aims and scope of your target journal | First day |
| 17.12.2026 | Conversation detective; reading; read the positioning sheets of your peers | First day |
| 18.12.2026 | Revise your contribution sentence; map the exemplar papers; reading | Second day |
| 22.12.2026 | Upload your revised manuscript | Mock review |
| 04.01.2027 | Write two reviews | Mock review |
| 07.01.2027 | Write one decision letter | Mock review |
| 08.01.2027 | Logics of inference, paradigms, and methods of your conversation | Third day |
Before Day 1
Please upload the following by Thursday, 03.12.2026:
- Manuscript: a current proposal, outline, or draft of one paper you are working on. Name the file with your family name first (e.g.,
Mueller_Draft.docx). - Positioning sheet (one page): discipline, association and subgroup (e.g., division, special interest group), literature strand, conversation, target outlet, and one sentence stating your intended contribution.
- Aims and scope: the aims and scope of your target journal (link or PDF); a peer uses it as editor in the desk-reject simulation.
Before the first day, complete the conversation detective, read Thatcher (2025) (Rules 1 to 5 and Appendix E), and read the positioning sheets of your peers, which you receive after the upload deadline.
Conversation Detective
Before the first day, reconstruct the conversation your manuscript joins from the literature itself. Plan about two to three hours.
- Seed: select two to three papers from your reference list that you consider central to your manuscript.
- Citation chasing: trace the conversation backward (the references of the seed papers) and forward (“Cited by” in Google Scholar), focusing on recent papers.
- Core identification: identify the papers that cite each other repeatedly; they form the core of the conversation. Note the most recent review article or special issue.
- Conversation map: name the conversation in one phrase and list a maximum of five journals, five authors, and five concepts or constructs.
- Self-check: mark which of the core papers your manuscript cites.
Bring your conversation map to the first day. You present it in about five minutes.
Tools such as Connected Papers, ResearchRabbit, or Litmaps generate citation graphs from seed papers and show clusters of papers that cite each other. The browser extension Rapid Journal Quality Check displays journal rankings next to Google Scholar results, which helps to identify the leading outlets of the conversation.
Before Day 2
After the first day:
- Revise your contribution sentence based on the desk-reject simulation and the assumption hunt.
- Read the three exemplar papers from your target outlet and note where their introductions place the motivation, the research question, and the contribution.
- Read Thatcher (2025), Rules 6 to 17.
- Bring the introduction and one theory or background section of your manuscript.
Mock Review
The self-study between the second and the third day simulates a review round.
- By 22.12.2026: upload your revised manuscript.
- By 04.01.2027: write two reviews as reviewer for the manuscripts of two peers, addressed to their target journals.
- By 07.01.2027: write one decision letter as editor for the manuscript of a third peer, based on its two reviews.
- Third day: draft a response matrix to the reviews and the decision letter you received.
| Manuscript | Reviewers | Editor |
|---|---|---|
| A | B, C | D |
| B | C, D | A |
| C | D, A | B |
| D | A, B | C |
Each manuscript receives two reviews and one decision letter, and each participant takes every role once: author, reviewer (twice), and editor. A review contains a short summary of the manuscript, the main concerns (positioning, contribution, theory, method, presentation), minor points, and a recommendation (reject, major revision, minor revision, accept). Number your points so that the author can respond to each one. Comment on argument, positioning, and structure first; language comes last.
As editor, you receive the two reviews on 04.01.2027. The decision letter states the decision, synthesizes the reviews into the three to five issues the revision has to address, and indicates where the reviewers disagree and which position the editor supports. The lecturer acts as editor-in-chief and comments on the decision letters on the third day.
Before Day 3
In addition to the mock review:
- Look up deductive, inductive, and abductive reasoning and classify your manuscript.
- Note keywords on positivist, interpretive, and critical research.
- Add the dominant methods of your conversation to your conversation map.
Expectations
- Regular attendance on all three days
- Active participation in discussions and peer rounds
- Provision of your own work for discussion
- Written reviews and a decision letter for the manuscripts of your peers
- Preparation of the materials provided